The Nice Law Firm, LLP

Bios

• 

  Robert J. Nice

  Managing Partner

  An Indiana native, Robert J. Nice has practiced law in Indiana for three decades. With a legal career that began in 1985, he focuses his practice in the areas of Real Estate; Small Business; Business Litigation; General Litigation; Legal Malpractice and Plaintiffs’ Personal Injury. Following law school Robert Nice was employed as an associate with a large Indianapolis law firm for six years before establishing his own firm in 1992. Utilizing his undergraduate degree, he also worked as a pharmacist before becoming an attorney and on a part time basis for several years thereafter. “When I graduated from law school in 1985, I did what all of the graduates were told to do. I went to work for a big law firm. As a consequence, I spent my days in the library or alone in my office writing briefs and responding to motions. I never saw clients. After six years, I’d had enough. I knew what to do; I just didn’t want to wait around for several years to have a chance to do it – so, I resigned and went off on my own. Since our firm’s inception in 1992, we have focused on providing our clients with personal attention, whether in a courtroom or an office setting. I particularly enjoy working with investors and small business owners. As a real estate investor, as well as an attorney, I have started and managed several small businesses over the years and fully understand the sacrifices business owners make and the effort they put forward to keep their businesses in operation. It requires a great effort and can provide great satisfaction. I invite you to call me personally to discuss how we can assist you in resolving the legal matters which you encounter in your life and in your business. We are here to help.”

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Robert J. Nice

• 

  John G. Shubat

  Attorney

  John is a lifelong resident of Zionsville, where he has been an active member of the community. He has served on the school board of Zionsville Community Schools, as well as the school board for Traders Point Christian Academy. He is a founding member of the Zionsville Education Foundation and, as an attorney, he has represented local civic organizations in various legal matters. John graduated from the Kelly School of Business at Indiana University and then worked in the medical and dental industry. After gaining experience in the business world, he decided he wanted to combine his business background with a legal education. He graduated cum laude from I.U. School of Law – Indianapolis and went to work for a large firm in Indianapolis, representing a wide variety of clients, from professionals accused of malpractice, to businesses involved in contract disputes. His experience includes local and federal courts, both at the trial and appellate court levels. He also has represented clients before licensing boards and in arbitration proceedings. Several years ago, he changed the focus of his practice and began to represent injured people to help them recover. Today, he continues to represent those who have been injured by the negligence of others, as well as representing people and businesses in a wide range of litigation disputes.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: John G. Shubat

• 

  Thomas Rethlake

  Attorney

  Thomas Rethlake, or T.J., as everyone calls him, interned at The Nice Law Firm while in law school and began his legal career at the firm immediately after passing the bar. He was sworn in on Thursday, started work the next Monday, and was representing clients in court on Tuesday. After several years of general practice, he focuses in the areas of Real Estate; Small Business; Business Litigation; General Litigation; Family Law; and Estate Law. Before and during law school, T.J. was employed as finance manager at a local car dealership. He utilizes his prior experience and undergraduate degree in finance and marketing to assist his business clients. T.J. is the recipient of the 2019 People’s Choice Award for Best Attorney in Kokomo.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Thomas Rethlake

• 

  Timothy Kappes

  Attorney

  A Zionsville resident, Timothy Kappes is an Indiana native and has been practicing law since 1987. As a Resident Attorney for Boone County and the surrounding counties, he focuses his general practice in the areas of llitigation, commercial transactions, estate planning and probate, family law, criminal law, personal injury, real estate, startup / early-stage and small business. Following law school, Tim Kappes served a number of years as a Deputy Attorney General for the State of Indiana and as a senior associate with a large Indiana-based law practice. He also has 15 years of in-house counsel and executive management experience with both publicly-traded corporations and early-stage / startup companies. This experience has included all aspects of legal affairs, commercial transactions, contracts, software license agreements, negotiation, regulatory compliance, corporate policy and governance, human resources / employment law, vendor relations and investor relations. Timothy and The Nice Law Firm team can help Hoosiers throughout the state with office locations in Indianapolis, Scottsburg, Terre Haute, Kokomo, Martinsville, Lebanon and Greensburg.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Timothy Kappes

• 

  Matthew V. Daley

  Attorney

  Matt Daley first moved to the Hoosier state in 2002 to attend college at Indiana University. Intent on declaring a computer science or a business major during his early college years, Matt took a business law class that would change everything. From that moment on, Matt knew he was destined to become a lawyer. He earned his undergraduate degree from Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana, and went on to attend law school at Indiana University Indianapolis, earning his juris doctorate in 2008. While attending law school, Matt worked as a certified intern and later went on to become a deputy prosecutor. As a former Marion County Deputy Prosecutor, he gained extensive courtroom and trial experience prosecuting drug and violent crime cases. It was during his two year stint as a prosecutor that Matt realized he had a passion and zeal for presenting oral arguments to a jury. In 2012, Matt was appointed a Public Defender in Vigo County, a role that allowed him to further hone his courtroom and advocacy skills on behalf of his clients in criminal law and family law cases. Matt founded his own law firm in 2012, which merged with The Nice Law Firm, LLP three years later. As a Resident Attorney with The Nice Law Firm, LLP (Terre Haute), Matt has expanded his areas of practice and has a dedicated team of legal support staff, as well as numerous attorney-colleagues he can turn to for assistance with all of the daily nuances associated with running a successful law practice. He has never looked back. An aggressive advocate on behalf of his criminal law clients, Matt views it to be a personal and professional honor to help individuals “who made one bad choice, one bad mistake, or were wrongfully arrested to prevent that one bad choice or mistake from destroying their life, or to at least do what I can to help mitigate the damage.” As a husband and father of two young sons, Matt understands all that is at stake for his family law clients seeking to end their marriages while doing the best they can to ensure the wellbeing of their children. He makes it his daily mission to help his family law clients work through difficult situations and arrive at the best outcome, so they can move forward in their lives.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Matthew V. Daley

• 

  Sean R. Moore

  Attorney

  Sean Moore brings a lot of legal experience with him having worked on the criminal defense team at Baldwin Perry & Kamish, P.C. He also has the following experience: The Criminal Defense Team of Baldwin Perry & Kamish, P.C.: Associate Attorney, 2019 to 2021 Marion County Prosecutor’s Office: Deputy Prosecutor, 2017 to 2019 Office of the Indiana Attorney General: Deputy Attorney General, Tax Litigation and Civil Litigation sections, 2016 to 2017 Preceded by a clerkship in the Criminal Appeals Division from 2015 to 2016 Sean and The Nice Law Firm team can help Hoosiers throughout the state with office locations in Indianapolis, Scottsburg, Terre Haute, Kokomo, Martinsville, Lebanon and Greensburg.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Sean R. Moore

• 

  Ashley N. Dayhuff

  Attorney

  Ashley Dayhuff was born and raised in Indianapolis, Indiana. She and her husband, Michael, are blessed with two beautiful children, Beau and Madelyn. Ashley started out her legal career in 2003 with an internship, which quickly turned into a job as a personal injury legal assistant from 2004-2008 during her undergraduate years at Indiana University Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI). Ashley obtained a bachelor’s degree in psychology from IUPUI with a minor in criminal justice. While an undergrad, Ashley received the Psychology Neel Award for graduating as the psychology major with the highest academic achievement. She then worked as a personal injury paralegal from 2008 to 2015. Ashley was admitted to the Bar in Indiana in September 2015 after obtaining her law degree from Indiana University Robert H. McKinney School of Law in May 2015. While a law student, Ashley excelled in her writing and oral classes. She was a Moot Court barrister in 2012, and she served as a Deans Tutorial Society (DTS) tutor from 2012-2014. Ashley cares for her clients, and she is dedicated to maintaining open, prompt, and thorough communication at all times. Because Ashley worked her way up from internship to legal assistant to paralegal to attorney, she knows the ins and outs of litigation from start to finish, and she promises to work diligently, professionally, and passionately for each and every client. When not working, Ashley spends the majority of her time with her family. She is passionate about her Lord and Savior, her family, and her career, and she also enjoys reading and scrapbooking.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Ashley N. Dayhuff

• 

  Don H. Wickens

  Attorney

  Don Wickens has been practicing law since 1961. He comes from a long line of attorneys. His family have been helping individuals and businesses in legal matters for more than 120 years. Securing the services of an attorney is essential when maneuvering through the complexities of the legal system and safeguarding your rights. Attorneys bring a wealth of expertise and experience to the table, enabling them to offer tailored legal advice pertinent to your unique circumstances. Whether you’re contending with criminal charges, involved in a civil dispute, or seeking guidance in business transactions, an attorney can provide invaluable support, strategize on your behalf, and vigorously advocate for your interests. Their thorough understanding of laws and regulations is instrumental in steering you away from costly errors and navigating intricate legal procedures with confidence. Moreover, attorneys excel in negotiating settlements, crafting precise legal documents, and representing you in court if necessary, all while ensuring your peace of mind and bolstering your chances of achieving a favorable resolution. Ultimately, enlisting the expertise of an attorney can significantly impact the outcome of your case, ensuring that justice prevails. Within the Greensburg vicinity, including Decatur County and its neighboring areas, Don distinguishes himself as the foremost attorney providing responsive and highly regarded legal counsel over numerous years. With a legacy steeped in committed service, Don takes pride in his skill as a proficient problem-solver. His efficient and results-driven methods have garnered him a strong reputation for achieving concrete outcomes. Whether you find yourself traversing the complexities of real estate law, pursuing estate planning goals, targeting real estate objectives, or addressing business planning necessities, we encourage you to arrange your initial consultation with him.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Don H. Wickens

• 

  Robert D. Wickens

  Attorney

  Robert Wickens has been practicing law since 2001. He comes from a long line of attorneys. His family have been helping individuals and businesses in legal matters for more than 120 years. Hiring an attorney is crucial for navigating the complexities of the legal system and ensuring your rights are protected. Attorneys bring expertise and experience to the table, allowing them to provide sound legal advice tailored to your specific situation. Whether you’re dealing with a criminal matter, civil dispute, or need assistance with business transactions, an attorney can offer invaluable guidance, strategize on your behalf, and advocate for your best interests. Their knowledge of laws and regulations can help you avoid costly mistakes and navigate intricate legal procedures effectively. Additionally, attorneys can negotiate settlements, draft legal documents, and represent you in court if necessary, providing peace of mind and increasing your chances of achieving a favorable outcome. Ultimately, hiring an attorney can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case and ensure justice is served. Timothy and The Nice Law Firm team can help Hoosiers throughout the state with office locations in Indianapolis, Scottsburg, Terre Haute, Kokomo, Martinsville, Lebanon and Greensburg. In the Greensburg area, encompassing Decatur County and its surroundings, Robert stands out as the premier lawyer offering responsive and esteemed legal representation for many years. With a legacy of dedicated service, Robert prides himself on being an adept problem-solver. His streamlined and effective approach has earned him a solid reputation for delivering tangible results. Whether you’re navigating a divorce, facing criminal charges, pursuing estate planning objectives, aiming for real estate milestones, or prioritizing business planning needs, we invite you to schedule your initial consultation with him.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Robert D. Wickens

• 

  Alexa D. Bischoff

  Attorney

  Alexa Bischoff was born and raised in Southern Indiana. She and her husband, Blake, have 3 wonderful children, Ellie, Brewster, and Audra. Alexa obtained a bachelor’s degree in English and Professional Writing from Indiana University and a law degree from Northern Kentucky University Salmon P. Chase College of Law, where she graduated as a W. Bruce Lunsford Academy Scholar. During law school, Alexa worked at a firm in Kentucky, assisting with criminal defense, personal injury, and family law matters. She was also involved with the Kentucky Innocence Project through an externship. Upon earning her law degree in May 2019, Alexa returned to Southern Indiana. She began her legal career as a Local Office Attorney for the Indiana Department of Child Services after she was admitted to the Indiana Bar in October 2019. Alexa later became a Deputy Prosecutor in Scott County and prosecuted felony and misdemeanor drug crimes. Alexa uses her knowledge and experience to advocate for her clients with both empathy and respect. When Alexa isn’t working, she is creating memories with her husband and 3 young children or is embracing her green thumb.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Alexa D. Bischoff

• 

  David A. Ratowitz

  Attorney

  Raised in Chicago, David Ratowitz attended the University of Iowa on an Army ROTC scholarship. Upon graduation, David was commissioned an officer, graduated from the Army’s elite Ranger School and served tours in the Republic of Korea and the 82nd Airborne Division. Upon leaving the Army, David earned his JD and MBA from Tulane University in New Orleans, LA where he founded a real estate firm specializing in historic renovations. After Hurricane Katrina David relocated his family to Chicago, IL and began practicing law, specializing in real estate and small business services. David moved to Brown County, IN in 2021 where he serves his community as a volunteer firefighter and a search and rescue technician. David joined the Nice Law Firm in 2024. Seeking the assistance of an attorney is imperative when navigating the intricacies of the legal system and protecting your rights. Attorneys bring a wealth of knowledge and experience to the table, enabling them to provide personalized legal advice tailored to your individual circumstances. Whether you’re facing criminal charges, embroiled in a civil dispute, or in need of guidance for business transactions, an attorney can offer invaluable assistance, strategize on your behalf, and vigorously advocate for your interests. Their comprehensive understanding of laws and regulations helps steer you away from costly mistakes and navigate complex legal procedures with confidence. Furthermore, attorneys are adept at negotiating settlements, drafting precise legal documents, and representing you in court when necessary, all while ensuring your peace of mind and enhancing your prospects for a favorable outcome. Ultimately, engaging the services of an attorney can have a significant impact on the outcome of your case, ensuring that justice is served.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: David A. Ratowitz

• 

  Jon Olinger

  Attorney

  Jon is a lifelong resident of Fort Wayne where he has consistently been a servant to his community. Jon sat for 12 years on the Fort Wayne Community School Board, serving as its President for two years. Jon received his B.S. in Marketing from Indiana University’s Fort Wayne campus in 1988 and worked in the transportation, construction, and real estate industry. In 2003 Jon received a dual Master of Business Administration in Entrepreneurial Studies and Human Resources. In 2013 Jon decided to combine his business and real estate valuation experience with a legal education and became a member of the Charter Class of Indiana Tech Law. In law school Jon was a member of the moot court team and editor in Chief of the Indiana Tech Law Review. Jon graduated Cum Lauda in 2016. Jon has practice Family, Criminal Law, and Estate Planning in Northern Indiana for over six years. He was the charter public defender tapped to help initiate Indiana’s very first CHINS based Domestic Violence Court. He has criminal and family trial experience and has focused on helping families through very tough times. Jon is married to Lisa and has two amazing daughters, four grandsons, and one great grandson. Jon works from our Fort Wayne, Indiana office. Obtaining the guidance of a lawyer is essential when maneuvering through the complexities of the legal system and safeguarding your rights. Lawyers bring extensive expertise and experience to the table, allowing them to offer tailored legal counsel suited to your specific situation. Whether you’re contending with criminal allegations, caught up in a civil disagreement, or seeking advice for business dealings, a lawyer can provide invaluable support, strategize on your behalf, and vigorously champion your interests. Their thorough grasp of laws and regulations helps steer you clear of costly errors and navigate intricate legal procedures with assurance. Moreover, lawyers excel in negotiating settlements, crafting precise legal documents, and representing you in court proceedings when necessary, all while ensuring your peace of mind and bolstering your chances for a positive resolution. Ultimately, enlisting the services of a lawyer can significantly influence the outcome of your case, ensuring that justice prevails.

  Education:

  Certifications:

  Services:

  Link: Jon Olinger